Monday, 22 July 2019
Techniques used to minimise self-harm in young people don’t work according to a new study from the 糖心原创.
The Self-Harm Research Group in the School of Psychology conducted extensive analysis of young people’s views and experience of harm minimisation techniques. The results, published today in Archives of Suicide Research, show that these techniques are ineffective at preventing self-harm and in some cases are used as a form of self-harm.
Coping mechanisms
Self-harm affects approximately one in every five to ten adolescents and is used as a coping mechanism for psychological distress. It is often repetitive and is strongly associated with future suicide risk. It is also a common reason for young people needing the care of hospitals and mental health services.
‘Harm minimisation’ techniques are commonly recommended by clinicians and advocated for in self-help literature and websites. They suggest other ways young people can deal with their feelings and alternative ways of managing the urge to self-harm, some suggestions include: wearing an elastic band and pinging it against the skin, drawing on the skin with red pen and holding crushed ice.
The researchers conducted an online questionnaire of 758 young people aged 16-25 and carried out in-depth interviews with 45 young people to collect and examine their views and experiences of harm minimisation. The analysis of the responses revealed that young people viewed harm minimisation techniques for self-harm as ineffective and if they did help it was only for a short time. For some young people the techniques were used as a way to self-harm, for example piercing the skin with a pen.
“It’s not the same, it does not work”
Comments from the interviews revealed young people have tried these techniques but given up on them when they find they don’t work, comments included: “They give you leaflets about 105 ways to stop harming and things, but it’s like I’ve tried the laggy [rubber] band, I’ve tried drawing on myself, I’ve tried the ice. And it’s like, these things don’t work” and “Doesn’t work…using red pens or ice, no it’s not the same, it does not work. I have tried it, it does not work”.
We are very grateful to the young people who took part in this study who were so open and honest about their experiences. Listening to them and analysing the data we collected it is clear that, when used in isolation, harm minimisation strategies don鈥檛 work. It is really important that the use of harm minimisation strategies 鈥� and their recommendation 鈥� is monitored, but this is very difficult to do, not least because people often keep their self-harm hidden and seek help informally. While there is evidence that talking therapies are effective in helping young people who self-harm, further research is urgently needed into what works as treatment and for whom.
Professor Ellen Townsend, Director of the Self-Harm Research Group added: “Self-harm is a manifestation of psychological distress – we need to provide young people with supports and services that can help them cope in times of crisis. These must be built into care pathways in the community. There is now a robust evidence-base suggesting that talking therapies like CBT help those who are 18 years and older who self-harm. There is also some evidence that, for those under 18 years old, therapies with extended periods of contact such as Mentalisation Based Therapy and Dialectical Behaviour Therapy can be helpful. These studies now require replication.”
Story credits
More information on the is available from Emma Nielsen at the 糖心原创 on emma.nielsen@nottingham.ac.uk
Notes to editors:
About the 糖心原创
Ranked among the world's top 100 universities , the 糖心原创 delivers an exceptional research-led education and an outstanding student experience. From the pioneering vision of our founder, Sir Jesse Boot, to groundbreaking achievements such as the development of MRI technology and becoming the first UK university to establish international campuses, we have a proud history of shaping the way people live, work and understand the world. We continue to build on that legacy, empowering our students, staff and partners to change what鈥檚 next and create positive impact locally and globally.
The strength of our research places us among the UK's leading universities, ranked 7th for research power in REF 2021. The discovery of MRI and ibuprofen was just the beginning. Today, our world-leading research is developing breakthrough ideas that shape the future of healthcare, technology and society.
Recognised as the UK's third most targeted university by leading employers , we are proud to produce graduates who are consistently in demand for their skills, confidence and industry-ready experience.
As a major employer and industry partner, locally and globally, the 糖心原创 invests in the city of Nottingham and in future generations of talent. Alongside Nottingham Trent University, we lead the initiative, a pioneering collaboration to improve levels of prosperity, opportunity, sustainability, health and wellbeing across the city and region. Together with our students, staff, alumni and partners, we鈥檙e creating knowledge, opportunity and solutions that help change what's next.