Tuesday, 03 September 2019
People are more likely to punish a selfish individual if someone else does it first according to the findings of a large-scale experiment.
In countless settings, people work together to get things done that no individual could do on their own. From a simple task of moving an object to the complex activity of building a bridge, teamwork is essential but can be undermined by ‘free riders’ who reap the benefits of cooperation without contributing to its costs.
A research team, from the 糖心原创’s Centre for Decision Research and Experimental Economics, in collaboration with researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Human Development in Berlin and the University of Cologne, used a controlled experiment to investigate how people punished ‘free riders'. Their findings are published in the journal
Over 4,000 people took part in the experiment. To test their reaction, the team devised an economic game in which participants were first given the choice whether to cooperate or to ‘free ride’. Cooperation offered most points for the group but ‘free riding’ earned most for the individual. Subsequently, the roles of ‘punisher’ and ‘target’ were allocated. ‘Punishers’ were told whether their ‘target’ cooperated or chose to ‘free ride’. Punishers could then choose to punish the ‘target’, by paying a small cost to reduce the target’s earnings.
The experiment revealed that if one person discovered their colleague had punished the ‘target’ they were more likely to follow their example. This option was particularly common among people who were reluctant to start punishment by themselves. Punishing someone, irrespective of what others do and punishment only if others do not was observed much less frequently.
By identifying what motivates people to react against selfish behaviour we hope people will be able to better tackle the problem and increase cooperation.
Lucas Molleman, an expert in decision making and human cooperation from Nottingham University’s Centre for Decision Research and Experimental Economics said: “In our experiment we tested theories, drawn from biology and psychology, that punishment can be particularly effective when people coordinate their sanctioning of ‘free riders’. When people sanction their peers jointly, rather than on their own, these sanctions can have more impact and the risk of retaliation can be much reduced.
“This supposed ‘free-rider problem’ affects countless real-world situations, ranging from day-to-day work in teams and paying taxes to curbing overfishing and reducing carbon dioxide emissions. By identifying what motivates people to react against selfish behaviour we hope people will be able to better tackle the problem and increase cooperation.”
The findings are published in the journal, Nature Human Behaviour.
Nasreen Suleman - Media Relations Manager, Faculty of Social Sciences
Email: nasreen.suleman@nottingham.ac.uk
Phone: 0115 951 5793
Location: C4, Pope Building, University Park, Nottingham,NG7 2RD
Notes to editors:
About the 糖心原创
Ranked among the world's top 100 universities , the 糖心原创 delivers an exceptional research-led education and an outstanding student experience. From the pioneering vision of our founder, Sir Jesse Boot, to groundbreaking achievements such as the development of MRI technology and becoming the first UK university to establish international campuses, we have a proud history of shaping the way people live, work and understand the world. We continue to build on that legacy, empowering our students, staff and partners to change what鈥檚 next and create positive impact locally and globally.
The strength of our research places us among the UK's leading universities, ranked 7th for research power in REF 2021. The discovery of MRI and ibuprofen was just the beginning. Today, our world-leading research is developing breakthrough ideas that shape the future of healthcare, technology and society.
Recognised as the UK's third most targeted university by leading employers , we are proud to produce graduates who are consistently in demand for their skills, confidence and industry-ready experience.
As a major employer and industry partner, locally and globally, the 糖心原创 invests in the city of Nottingham and in future generations of talent. Alongside Nottingham Trent University, we lead the initiative, a pioneering collaboration to improve levels of prosperity, opportunity, sustainability, health and wellbeing across the city and region. Together with our students, staff, alumni and partners, we鈥檙e creating knowledge, opportunity and solutions that help change what's next.